RSS Feed     Twitter     Facebook

Posts Tagged ‘guardian.co.uk’

Amnesty condemns Nicaragua abortion ban

Amnesty report details shocking effects of country’s penal code which criminalises abortions in all cases

Nicaragua’s ban on all abortions, even when a woman’s life is at risk, is compelling incest and rape victims to give birth and contributing to an increase in maternal deaths, according to a report from Amnesty International.

Delegates from the human rights charity, who recently visited the predominantly Catholic country, say young girls subjected to sexual violence by family or friends are forced to give birth even when they are carrying their own brothers and sisters.

The report also says the law has led to a recorded rise in pregnant teenagers committing suicide by consuming poison.

Official figures show 33 girls and women died in pregnancy in the past year, compared to 20 in the previous year, it says. But the numbers are feared to be greater as the government itself has acknowleged incidents of maternal deaths are under-recorded.

Abortion was a key issue for the 2006 presidential election, won by former Sandinista leader Daniel Ortega. The former revolutionary, who once supported abortion rights, mobilised his supporters behind a campaign for a blanket ban on terminations, which was signed into law just before he took office.

Previous to that, “therapeutic” abortions were allowed in certain circumstances where continuation of the pregnancy was life-threatening.

The new penal code, introduced in July last year, enshrined the criminalisation of abortion, regardless of circumstance, with prison sentences for women who undergo abortions, and the medical staff who help them.

It also introduced criminal sanctions for doctors and nurses who treat a pregnant woman or girl for illnesses such as cancer, malaria, HIV/Aids or cardiac emergencies if such treatment could cause injury to or lead to the death of the embryo or foetus.

“There is only one way to describe what we have seen in Nicaragua ‑ sheer horror,” Kate Gilmore, Amnesty International’s executive deputy secretary general, told a press conference in Mexico City. “Children are being compelled to bear children. Pregnant women are being denied essential life saving medical care.”

She added: “What alternatives is this government offering a 10-year-old pregnant as a result of rape? And a cancer sufferer who is denied life-saving treatment just because she is pregnant, while she has other children waiting at home?”

Amnesty said the law goes as far as punishing girls and women who have suffered a miscarriage, as in many cases it is impossible to distinguish spontaneous from induced abortions.

The charity is calling for the immediate repeal of the penal code, and a guarantee of safe and accessible abortion services for rape victims and women whose lives or health would be at risk from the continuation of pregnancy. It also wants protection for those who speak out against the law, and “comprehensive” support to be given to women and girls affected by it.

The report, The total abortion ban in Nicaragua: Women’s lives and health endangered, medical professionals criminalised claims the law is in conflict with the Nicaraguan obstetric rules and protocols issued by the ministry of health, which mandates therapeutic abortions in specific cases.

The church has been seen as a powerful force behind the ban in a country where an estimated 85% of the population is Catholic. Just 3% of the world’s countries, including El Salvador and Chile, have such an absolute ban in place.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


Kenya to build £533m windfarm

With surging demand for power and blackouts common across the continent, Africa is looking to solar, wind and geothermal technologies to meet its energy needs

One of the hottest places in the world is set to become the site of Africa’s most ambitious venture in the battle against global warming. 

Some 365 giant wind turbines are to be installed in desert around Lake Turkana in northern Kenya – used as a backdrop for the film The Constant Gardener – creating the biggest windfarm on the continent. When complete in 2012, the £533m project will have a capacity of 300MW, a quarter of Kenya’s current installed power and one of the highest proportions of wind energy to be fed in a national grid anywhere in the world. 

Until now, only north African countries such as Morocco and Egypt have harnessed wind power for commercial purposes on any real scale on the continent. But projects are now beginning to bloom south of the Sahara as governments realise that harnessing the vast wind potential can efficiently meet a surging demand for electricity and ending blackouts. 

Already Ethiopia has commissioned a £190m, 120MW farm in Tigray region, representing 15% of the current electricity capacity, and intends to build several more. Tanzania has announced plans to generate at least 100MW of power from two projects in the central Singida region, more than 10% of the country’s current supply. In March, South Africa, whose heavy reliance on coal makes its electricity the second most greenhouse-gas intensive in the world, became the first African country to announce a feed-in tariff for wind power, whereby customers generating electricity receive a cash payment for selling that power to the grid.

Kenya is trying to lead the way. Besides the Turkana project, which is being backed by the African Development Bank, private investors have proposed establishing a second windfarm near Naivasha, the well-known tourist town. And in the Ngong hills near Nairobi, the Maasai herders and elite long-distance athletes used to braving the frigid winds along the escarpment already have towering company: six 50m turbines from the Danish company Vestas that were erected last month and will add 5.1MW to the national grid from August. Another dozen turbines will be added at the site in the next few years. 

Christopher Maende, an engineer from the state power company KenGen, which is running the Ngong farm and testing 14 other wind sites across the country, said local residents and herders were initially worried that noise from the turbines would scare the animals. 

“Now they are coming to admire the beauty of these machines,” he said. 

Kenya’s electricity is already very green by global standards. Nearly three-quarters of KenGen’s installed capacity comes from hydropower, and a further 11% from geothermal plants, which tap into the hot rocks a mile beneath the Rift Valley to release steam to power turbines. 

Currently fewer than one-in-five Kenyans has access to electricity but demand is rising quickly, particularly in rural areas and from businesses. At the same time, increasingly erratic rainfall patterns and the destruction of key water catchment areas have affected hydroelectricity output. Low water levels caused the country’s largest hydropower dam to be shut down last month. 

As a short-term measure KenGen is relying on imported fossil fuels, such as coal and diesel. But within five years the government wants to drastically reduce the reliance on hydro by adding 500MW of geothermal power and 800MW of wind energy to the grid. 

Not only are they far greener options than coal or diesel, but the country’s favourable geology and meteorology make them cheaper alternatives over time. The possibility of selling carbon credits to companies in the industrialised world is an added financial advantage. 

“Kenya’s natural fuel should come from the wind, hot underground rock and the sun, whose potential has barely even been considered,” said Nick Nuttall, spokesman for the United Nations Environment Programme. “After the initial capital costs this energy is free.” 

The Dutch consortium behind the Lake Turkana Wind Power (LTWP) project has leased 66,000 hectares of land on the eastern edge of the world’s largest permanent desert lake. The volcanic soil is scoured by hot winds that blow consistently year round through the channel between the Kenyan and Ethiopian highlands.

According to LTWP, which has an agreement to sell its electricity to the Kenya Power & Lighting Company, the average wind speed is 11metres per second, akin to “proven reserves” in the oil sector, said Carlo Van Wageningen, chairman of the company. 

“We believe that this site is one of the best in the world for wind,” he said. If the project succeeds, the company estimates that there is the potential for the farm to generate a further 2,700MW of power, some of which could be exported.

First, however, there are huge logistical obstacles to overcome. The remote site of Loiyangalani is nearly 300 miles north of Nairobi. Transporting the turbines will require several thousand truck journeys, as well as the improvement of bridges and roads along the way. Security is also an issue as the region is known bandit country, and many locals are armed with AK-47 assault rifles. 

LTWP also has to construct a 266-mile transmission line and several substations to connect the windfarm to the national grid. It has promised to provide electricity to the closest local towns, currently powered by generators. 

The greening of Africa

At the end of 2008, Africa’s installed wind power capacity was only 593MW. But that is set to change fast. Egypt has declared plans to have 7,200MW of wind electricity by 2020, meeting 12% of the country’s energy needs. Morocco has a 15% target over the same period. South Africa and Kenya have not announced such long-term goals, but with power shortages and wind potential of up to 60,000MW and 30,000MW respectively, local projects are expected to boom. With the carbon credit market proving strong incentives for investment other types of renewable energy are also set to take off. Kenya is planning to quickly expanding its geothermal capacity, and neighbouring Rift Valley countries up to Djibouti are examining their own potential. As technology improves and costs fall, solar will also enter the mix. Germany has already publicised plans to develop a €400bn solar park in the Sahara.

“Ultimately for Africa solar is the answer, although [costs mean] we may still be decades away,” said Herman Oelsner, president of the African Wind Energy Association.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


Archbishop warns against gay clergy

Rowan Williams says stand taken by US Episcopals could cause isolation and relegation in Anglican communion

The archbishop of Canterbury today reiterated his opposition to ordaining gay clergy and authorising same-sex blessings, warning liberal churches that such practices would lead to isolation and relegation in the Anglican communion.

Rowan Williams was responding in a statement today to developments in the US Episcopal church which earlier this month voted to open the ordination process to gay people and to consider developing blessings for same-sex couples.

In typically lengthy and nuanced prose, the archbishop said that the church’s stance on these matters was unlikely to “repair the broken bridges in the life of the other Anglican provinces” and that “very serious anxieties had already been expressed” in the communion.

Same-sex blessings were “at the very least analogous” to Christian marriage and people living in such unions could not “without serious incongruity” have a representative function in a church whose public teaching was “at odds with their lifestyle”, he said.

This disparity in theology and practice between conservatives and liberals – exacerbated by the consecration of Gene Robinson in 2003 as the communion’s first bishop in a relationship with another man – would lead to a “twofold ecclesial reality”, he added.

“Perhaps we are faced with the possibility of a two-track model, two ways of witnessing Anglican heritage, one of which had decided that local autonomy had to be the prevailing value.”

Those Anglican provinces accepting the covenant – a good behaviour guide for churches – would be able to participate fully in communion matters and in ecumenical and interfaith dialogue. Those who thought it more important to adhere to local pressures would have a lesser, unofficial, role in the life of the communion because there had to be clarity “about who has the authority to speak for whom”.

Williams has been pushing the covenant as the only way to heal the rift between warring factions, but it has found little favour with the Episcopal church, which sees the document as disproportionately punitive towards churches that are more inclusive and liberal.

Neither Williams nor the covenant does enough to tackle the issue of African churches interfering in US parishes, say Episcopalians, interventions that have seen conservative churches flock to African archbishops and bishops for spiritual leadership. In an act of rebellion, some Episcopalians broke away earlier this year to form their own church.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


US presses Israel on settlements

Middle East envoy George Mitchell reportedly discussing deal to allow completion of homes currently under construction

Barack Obama has dispatched a clutch of senior American officials to Jerusalem to press his demand for an end to Jewish settlement construction and move along a diplomatic process aimed at imposing a blueprint for peace if negotiations fail.

Obama’s Middle East envoy, George Mitchell, is reportedly discussing a deal with the Israeli leadership that would allow the completion of several thousand homes for Jewish settlers already under construction but impose a total halt to building once they are complete. Such an agreement would amount to a concession by Obama, who laid down an immediate and complete freeze on construction as a marker of a more interventionist policy at a testy meeting with the Israeli prime minister, Binyamin Netanyahu, in Washington in May.

But American sources close to the negotiations say that getting Netanyahu to agree that no new construction can begin is an important step toward forcing a new diplomatic process that is no longer hostage to Israeli intransigence.

The diplomatic moves came as the Israeli military announced that the number of Jewish settlers on the West Bank has risen above 300,000 for the first time with about 200,000 more in East Jerusalem. About 2.5 million Palestinians live in the same territory.

The US defence secretary, Robert Gates, is also in Israel as part of the drive to secure a comprehensive Middle East peace agreement.

The aim is to win a regional consensus on Iran’s nuclear programme but also reassure the Israelis that Washington has not gone soft on the issue in an effort to dampen Israeli threats of military action. Gates said he did not believe that Barack Obama’s timetable would “increase the risks to anybody” — a reference to Israeli concerns that its nuclear monopoly may soon be challenged by the Islamic republic.

Israel has hinted at a pre-emptive attack on Iran should it deem diplomacy to be at a dead end. Prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office said today that he reaffirmed to Gates “the need to use all means to prevent Iran from obtaining nuclear military capability”.

While the Obama administration continues to say that negotiation is the way forward, Gates today said that the promise of talks with Iran “is not an open-ended offer”.

Two other US officials are also visiting Jerusalem as part of the diplomatic push – Obama’s national security adviser, James Jones, who in an Israeli diplomatic memo was reported to have told European officials that the administration will take a hard line with the Israelis, and Dennis Ross, Bill Clinton’s special envoy to the peace process who was brought back to focus on Iran.

The immediate effort is around a settlement freeze.

Tel Aviv newspapers report that Israeli officials say that talks are moving toward a deal in which the Americans will permit the completion of 700 buildings with nearly 2,500 new homes in them that are already well under construction, mostly in two settlements close to the green line which are likely to fall inside the Jewish state’s border under a final agreement.

But as part of the agreement, the US intends to rigorously monitor the building work to ensure that the Israelis do not push it beyond the agreed limits.

The Americans are acutely aware that in the past Israel has agreed to contain settlement expansion and then promptly broken its word. This time the US is insisting on detailed plans of what would amount to a final bout of construction before a total halt to building comes in to force.

Mitchell is also pressuring Arab countries for gestures in response to an Israeli settlement freeze such as trade delegations or overflight rights.

Mitchell said at a press conference that the disagreement over settlement construction is a “discussion among friends” but it is also a test of Obama’s authority.

One former official who monitors the negotiations closely said that the US is prepared to give ground because it sees a settlement freeze as an important step toward reviving Israeli-Palestinian talks.

There is no great expectation in Washington that talks will go anywhere but that they should have been tried and failed once again will help smooth the diplomatic path for the administration’s plan to force its own proposals on to the table later this year which could force Israel to make significant territorial concessions.

The Palestinians have been insistent that there can be no talks without a settlement freeze.

That still leaves the question of Jerusalem as a major obstacle.

Netanyahu very forthrightly spurned US demands to block a new settlement project in the occupied east of the city where an American millionaire plans to bulldoze an old hotel and build Jewish-only housing.

The prime minister said that Israel will not be dictated to on where its citizens can live in what it says is its eternal and indivisible capital. Netanyahu later said that all of Jerusalem will remain under Israeli jurisdiction even after a peace settlement.

Some American officials think Netanyahu may be overplaying his hand because if he puts himself in a position where he is unable to give ground on Jerusalem, that will require others to lay down Israel’s final borders.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


150 dead in Nigerian ‘Taliban’ battles

Islamic group opposed to western education, Boko Haram, launches attacks across four northern provinces

A self-styled “Taliban” intent on imposing sharia law on all Nigerians widened its offensive yesterday in violence that has left 150 people dead.

Boko Haram, an Islamic group opposed to western education, has launched attacks across four northern provinces over the last two days and declared its intention to fight to the death.

Civilians were pulled from their cars and shot, their corpses then left scattered around the streets, witnesses told the BBC. Its reporter counted 100 bodies, mostly those of militants, near police headquarters in Maiduguri, Borno state. The police and army were on patrol, firing into the air, as hundreds of people fled their homes.

Witnesses said a separate gun battle raged for hours in Potiskum, Yobe state, where members of Boko Haram chanted “God is great!” as they set a police station ablaze. Two people were confirmed dead and the police made 23 arrests.

Three people were killed and more than 33 arrested in Wudil, 12 miles from Kano, the biggest city in northern Nigeria, while the town’s senior police officer was wounded.

Nigeria, Africa’s most populous country, has more than 200 ethnic groups and is roughly equally split between Christians and Muslims. The predominantly Muslim north has progressively ushered in a stricter enforcement of sharia law since 2000.

Boko Haram, which models itself on the Taliban but has no known link, began its string of attacks in the northeastern city of Bauchi on Sunday after some of its members were arrested.

Around 70 militants armed with guns and grenades targeted a police station but were driven back by officers and soliders who then raided neighbourhoods, resulting in at least 55 deaths and up to 200 arrests. The Bauchi state governor imposed a night-time curfew as a result.

Ustaz Mohammed Yusuf, leader of Boko Haram, which literally means “education is prohibited”, claimed that the government had been targeting his followers and they would never surrender.

He told Nigeria’s Daily Trust newspaper: “What I said previously that we are going to be attacked by the authorities has manifested itself in Bauchi, where about 40 of our brothers were killed, their mosque and homes burnt down completely and several others were injured and about 100 are presently in detention. Therefore, we will not agree with this kind of humiliation, we are ready to die together with our brothers and we would never concede to non-belief in Allah.”

He added: “I will not give myself up. If Allah wishes, they will arrest me; if Allah does not wish, they will never arrest me. But I will never give up myself, not after 37 of my followers are killed in Bauchi. Is it right to kill them, is it right to shoot human beings? To surrender myself means what they did is right. Therefore, we are ready to fight to die.

“Democracy and the current system of education must be changed otherwise this war that is yet to start would continue for long.”

Bauchi, Yobe, Borno and Kanoare among the 12 of Nigeria’s 36 states that started a stricter enforcement of Islamic law in 2000 – a decision that has alienated sizeable Christian minorities and sparked bouts of sectarian violence that has killed thousands.

Clashes in Bauchi in February killed at least 11 people and wounded dozens. A Muslim group attacked Christians and burned churches in reprisals over the burning of two mosques, which Muslims blamed on Christians.

Last November, more than 700 people were killed in two days of fighting in the central city of Jos after a disputed election triggered the worst fighting between Muslim and Christian gangs in years.

Boko Haram is not connected to the Movement for the Emancipation of the Niger Delta, the prominent rebel group responsible for a campaign of violence that has battered Africa’s biggest energy sector, located in Nigeria, since early 2006.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


Eye injury could end Massa’s career

• ‘We don’t know if he’ll be able to race again’ says doctor
• ‘Improving’ Massa visited by Barrichello and Brawn

Felipe Massa’s Formula One career appears to be hanging in the balance following confirmation that he has suffered some damage to his left eye.

Massa is in intensive care at the AEK military hospital in Budapest after suffering a skull fracture following a freak accident on Saturday during qualifying for the Hungarian grand prix.

Although the 28-year-old, still in a medically induced coma, has shown signs of improvement after undergoing emergency surgery, it has emerged that Massa may have sustained eye problems. If that is the case, and the Brazilian is unable to see properly in the future, it will mean his days in motor racing are over.

Professor Robert Veres said: “He has suffered some damage to the eye. We don’t know if he’ll be able to race again.”

Earlier today it was reported that Massa had “a quiet night” as he continued his recovery.

After yesterday’s race at the Hungaroring, Massa was visited by the Ferrari team principal, Stefano Domenicali, team-mate Kimi Raikkonen and the Brawn GP driver Rubens Barrichello and team principal, Ross Brawn.

It was a spring that had worked loose on Barrichello’s car that hit Massa on his helmet at 162mph, causing his injuries and subsequent crash into a tyre barrier.

A Ferrari spokesman said: “Felipe had a quiet night. He is OK, and he is due to have another CT scan today.”

Doctors at the hospital were encouraged by the positive results of yesterday’s first CT scan following surgery and hoped that Massa would continue to show steady improvement.

A spokesman for the Hungarian defence ministry, under whose jurisdiction the hospital is run, has been quoted as saying on local television that Massa is starting to “communicate actively”.

“He reacts when he’s spoken to. We are optimistic a slow recovery is beginning,” said Istvan Bocskai, who also confirmed Massa could move his hands and legs.

FIA president Max Mosley has, meanwhile, asked for an investigation to be launched into recent debris-related accidents in Formula One and Formula Two.

The FIA safety commission, which is made up of medical and technical representatives from all areas of motor sport, will submit a report and recommendations to the world motor sport council.

It follows the incident involving Massa and the death of the teenage Formula Two driver Henry Surtees at Brands Hatch when his car was struck by a wheel which had come off a rival’s car.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


Terry’s five weeks of silence

Perhaps Chelsea’s captain spent all summer struggling to find the words to describe his selfless loyalty towards the club

Let’s take John Terry’s word for it. Let’s assume he was telling the truth when he said that “I am totally committed to Chelsea and always have been”. When all’s said and done, only the archest of cynics would doubt the sincerity of a top-flight professional footballer issuing the written equivalent of a crest-kiss-with-clenched-fist, because anyone with a passing interest in the game knows it is not populated by players, or indeed managers, with form in the field of dishonest declarations of loyalty.

Some have questioned the bona fides of Terry’s oath of allegiance on the grounds that it was pledged after five weeks of complete radio silence, a period long enough to prompt acerbic suggestions that “Mr Chelsea” was displaying a certain amount of contempt for his club and those who support it. If he knew Chelsea’s supporters were on tenterhooks waiting to hear his plans and knew there was no question of him leaving Stamford Bridge, why did he wait for more than a month to offer any kind of reassurance?

While it’s possible he was suffering from a particularly nasty throat infection that had rendered him speechless, it seems obvious that Terry is so committed to Chelsea that he was prepared to waste the best part of his summer holidays with spiral notebook in hand, sitting in an armchair surrounded by scrunched-up balls of paper, sucking furiously on his pencil as he struggled to find the exact words required to describe the selfless loyalty we now know he feels towards his club and its fans.

These same fans should be wary, however, as Terry’s statement reveals him to be a man so lacking in ambition that he was unprepared to even consider the prospect of signing for a club whose financial clout and relentless, if ultimately unsuccessful, pursuit of the world’s best players and John Terry has been well documented. Let’s face it, a player so reluctant to even think about leaving his comfort zone is unlikely to stray out of position to cover for Jose Bosingwa or Ashley Cole the next time either full-back is left horribly exposed.

Chelsea supporters could also be forgiven for questioning the smarts of a player whose steadfast refusal to use the interest of a club reportedly prepared to double his wages as leverage with which to secure a new, improved contract from his current employers suggests he may well be several sandwiches short of a picnic. Equally incomprehensible lapses of judgment on the field of play during the coming months would almost certainly scupper his team’s chances of bagging a major trophy.

These are interesting times for Chelsea fans, who will be preparing for the season ahead with some trepidation now that their club’s captain, whose carefully considered utterances have revealed him to be something of an ambition-free dolt. The scarcely plausible alternative, that he’s yet another calculating mercenary who held his club to ransom before fobbing off its fans with a transparent and misleading sop, is unlikely to reassure them.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


Consumer watchdog victim of ‘fraud’

Embarrassment for OFT after its annual report reveals alleged fraud and compensation payment to staff member

It spends a lot of time warning the public about the dangers of scams, but Britain’s main consumer watchdog today revealed that it believes it has lost £250,000 after falling victim to an alleged fraud.

The admission was tucked away at the back of the Office of Fair Trading’s annual report for the last financial year, which sets out its achievements and the value for money it is delivering for British consumers.

The OFT said it had suffered “a cash loss of £250,000, of which £97,000 occurred in 2008-09, and £153,000 occurred in 2007-08″. “This was due to an alleged fraud made possible by a control weakness in the Accounts Payable process,” it said.

The watchdog was unable to say much more as the matter was the subject of legal proceedings, it added. It is understood that a former member of staff has been charged with an offence.

The report also revealed that, in a separate matter, the OFT handed over more than £250,000 in the form of a “special payment for compensation” to a member of its staff. “We don’t divulge that kind of thing,” a spokesman said when asked about the nature of the compensation payout.

The watchdog said the work it had been doing on consumer protection, competition enforcement, merger control and investigating markets had saved the British public around £409m a year between 2006 and 2009.

“This means it delivered financial benefits to consumers of around eight times its average annual costs of £53m, and exceeded the five-times cost target set by HM Treasury,” the spokesman said.

Its achievements during the year included:

• Launching its first criminal investigation under the consumer protection regulations – into an alleged unlawful pyramid scheme

• Securing the first UK criminal convictions for cartel participants in a case involving marine hoses, which are used to transfer oil from tankers to storage facilities

• Investigating alleged unlawful pricing practices in dairy and tobacco products, and alleged bid-rigging in the construction industry

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


The great Renaissance art cover-up

The 16th-century notion of creating artworks purely to hide and cover over secret paintings raises questions about why these concealed works existed at all

Why do some paintings need to be covered up? In the seductive display of Titian’s Triumph of Love, currently at the National Gallery, you discover that the Venetian master painted this sensual image of Cupid as a “cover” for another painting. This means a second canvas that fitted over and concealed a picture beneath. It was not that rare a practice in the Renaissance. But why? Were the concealed paintings rude, or dangerous, or in some way heretical?

I love this image of the secret painting, the occult artwork that needs to be hidden from prying eyes. Triumph of Love was apparently a cover for a portrait of a woman – but was she a mistress, a courtesan? What made her portrait illicit?

I saw another example of a cover in the Uffizi Gallery in Florence last week that casts light on why such portraits were hidden. Pygmalion and Galatea, by the great Florentine mannerist Agnolo Bronzino, depicts a young man kneeling in prayer to the goddess Venus. Behind him, a sacrificial fire blazes in a bleak hilly landscape.

Bronzino painted this as a cover for his teacher Jacopo Pontormo’s Portrait of Francesco Guardi. Pontormo’s painting is a sensuous yet heroic image of a young citizen soldier. Guardi stands in cream and red with a sword at his hip and a halberd in his hand. It was painted when the Florentine Republic was under attack in 1529; the youth is a volunteer soldier ready to defend his city.

The Republic was crushed after a siege in which tens of thousands of people died. The Medici family imposed a dukedom on the city and hounded down dissidents. This must be why Bronzino was asked to paint a cover for his master’s work – so that the Guardi family could keep a blatantly subversive, Republican portrait discreetly veiled from prying eyes.

The true secret of covers is that Renaissance paintings are full of subversion and heterodoxy. Bronzino’s cover, with its blazing pyre and barren trees, alludes to the horrors of tyranny even as it covers a libertarian image.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


How it feels to be sued for filesharing

When I contemplate the above sum, I have to remind myself what I’m being charged with. Investment fraud? An attack against the government? No. I shared music. And refused to cave

To a certain extent, I’m afraid to write this. Though they’ve already seized my computer and copied my hard drive, I have no guarantee they won’t do it again. For the past four years, they’ve been threatening me, making demands for trial, deposing my parents, sisters, friends, and myself twice – the first time for nine hours, the second for seven. I face up to $4.5m in fines and the last case like mine that went to trial had a jury verdict of $1.92m.

When I contemplate this, I have to remind myself what I’m being charged with. Investment fraud? Robbing a casino? A cyber-attack against the federal government? No. I shared music. And refused to cave.

No matter how many people I explain this to, the reaction is always the same: dumbfounded surprise and visceral indignance, both of which are a result of the amazing secrecy the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) has operated under. “How did they get you?” I’m asked. I explain that there are 40,000 people like me, being sued for the same thing, and we were picked from a pool of millions who shared music. And that’s when a look appears on the face of whoever I’m talking to, the horrified “it could have been me!” look.

The reason this has remained so silent despite passionate opposition is that nearly all people settle. My story of becoming an exception started four years ago.

In 2005, my parents received a letter from Sony BMG, Warner, Atlantic Records, Arista Records, and UMG Records claiming “copyright infringement”. They were given a number to call, which was their “settlement information line”, a call centre staffed by operators who, we are emphatically told, are “not attorneys”. The process of collecting money from these threats was so huge, they had set up a 1-800-DONT-SUE-ME-style call centre.

The operators did little more than ask how you would pay (they wanted $3,000, I believe) and repeated intimidating lawsuit statistics. I sent them a money order for $500, which they returned. I told them I couldn’t pay any more. We discussed whether I might qualify for “financial hardship”, and then I stopped hearing from them, which I didn’t question. I graduated from college and began studying for my physics doctorate.

And then in August 2007, I came home from work to find a stack of papers, maybe 50 pages thick, sitting at the door to my apartment. That’s when I found out what it was like to have possibly the most talented copyright lawyers in the business, bankrolled by multibillion-dollar corporations, throwing everything they had at someone who wanted to share Come As You Are with other Nirvana fans.

I had assumed that as an equal in a court of law in the United States, my story would be told and a just outcome would result. I discovered the sheer magnitude of obstacles in your way to get your say in court. And even if you get to trial, (which only one other person, Jammie Thomas Rasset, has done) you’re still far from equal with the machine controlling 85% of commercial music in the US.

But to even start fighting assumes you (a) know what you’re even being sued for and (b) have a concept of what grounds to fight it on. Most of the time you know nothing except for the huge stack of paper written in legalese that says you owe several thousand dollars and it will probably cost you more than that just to hire a lawyer. If you can find one.

I had frequent contact with one of their Colorado counsel. While she was impudent to the point of vicious (“Come on Joel, I think you did it”), I continued to use phrases like “I respect your position” and “we have a respectful difference of opinion”. I have no record of this intimidation because the person in question made sure to keep contact restricted to phonecalls.

Every conversation consisted of her trying to get information out of me about my defense, telling me how much bigger the settlement would be if I didn’t settle now. Shaken, I would call my mother, who was a state-paid lawyer in child custody cases, and ask her what to do. We blindly fired all kinds of motions at them. Eventually my mother became afraid to answer my calls, worried it would be about the case. For the court “settlement” I offered $5,250, which the RIAA declined, asking $10,500. I saw myself on a conveyor belt, being pulled inexorably toward the meshing of razor-sharp gears.

Then in summer 2008, I arrived home to find a letter addressed to me. The return address said “Harvard Law School”. Curiously, I opened and read it. “My name is Charles Nesson, professor of Law at Harvard. I caught wind of your case,” it said. “I can be of any assistance, don’t hesitate to call.” I called. Nesson picked up. I said, “Yes, you can be of assistance!” My mom drafted a letter to him, summarising where we were. The opening line read, “Dear Professor Godsend”.

Since then I’ve learned that you don’t have to accept phone contact from the RIAA lawyers, but could demand correspondence by mail. I’ve been deposed twice – for nine hours one day and for another seven a few weeks ago – where I was asked every irrelevant question about my life, cars that I owned, websites I’ve operated. The RIAA will try to denigrate this, saying I was only talking for seven hours and then five and a half, but I was stuck in their office the entire time. You think it makes any difference to me when I can’t work?

My sisters, dad and mother have all been deposed. My high-school friends, friends of the family too. My computer’s been seized and hard drive copied, and my parents and sister narrowly escaped the same fate for their computers. And the professor who supervises my teaching is continually frustrated with my need to have people cover for me, while my research in grad school is put on hold to deal with people whose full-time job is to keep an anvil over my head. I have to consider every unrelated thing I do in my private life in the event that I’m interrogated under oath about it. I wonder how I’ll stand up in a courtroom for hours having litigators try to convince a jury of my guilt and the reprehensibility of my character.

But the support helps. I’ve had a great team of Nesson’s students helping and the professor himself has been magnificent. Most of all, I’m touched by the warm messages of support from the people who’ve written in, Twittered, and Facebooked me (though I’ve been too paranoid to friend strangers lately). Best hopes to others dealing with the same: Brittany Kruger, Jammie Thomas, and the other 39,997 of us.

The trial starts today, 27 Monday July. Regrettably, it won’t be webcast as we requested due to the RIAA’s successful opposition, but we will tweet (with the hashtag #jfb) and blog as much as possible, and there is a website where you can follow us and learn more.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


How would you prosecute the PM?

Corinna Ferguson talks Zasta through the rare, and costly, route of bringing private prosecutions against breaches of criminal law

Zasta asks:

“Are there any guidelines to help members of the public bring prosecutions against prominent public figures?How would you go about prosecuting the PM, the Queen or a head of the police force if you felt they were in breach of the law?

For example, Mark Thomas’s attempt to prosecute Gordon Brown for infringing SOCPA or if an individual felt that fraud had been committed during the MPs’ expenses scandal?”

Although there has always been a right to bring private prosecutions for breaches of the criminal law – indeed before 1879 there was no public prosecutor so it was the only way that anyone came before the criminal courts – it is a rarely-used procedure. There are a number of reasons for this. First, the police and prosecuting authorities have a duty to investigate and prosecute breaches of the criminal law, and they should only refuse to do so if they consider there is insufficient evidence or it is not in the public interest to prosecute. Second, private prosecutions are expensive to bring and entail a risk of being ordered to pay the defendant’s costs. Third, it will often be difficult for a private individual to gather sufficient evidence t o meet the high standards of proof which apply in criminal cases. Finally, the Crown Prosecution Service has the power to take over any private prosecution and thereafter to continue or discontinue it.

The first port of call for anyone who believes that a crime has been committed is to refer the matter to the police and/or the director of public prosecutions. This is what Mark Thomas was intending to do after Gordon Brown failed to obtain authorisation for what Thomas thought might amount to a “demonstration” in Parliament Square. However the question of whether all of the elements of an offence are present, or whether it is the public interest to prosecute may be highly contentious, and it is extremely difficult to challenge a decision of the DPP not to prosecute. So a private prosecution may be the only option for someone determined to see the matter in court and willing to take the financial risk.

The procedure was famously used in the Jerry Springer: The Opera blasphemy case that Anna Fairclough talked about in last week’s clinic. The prosecution was unsuccessful but the court did not question the right of a private individual, to bring the case in principle. Another well-known example of a private prosecution followed the Marchioness disaster in 1989. The high court upheld the right of the widower of one of the 51 victims to bring a prosecution for manslaughter against the owner and four employees of the dredger which had sunk the Marchioness pleasure boat. The court rejected the defendant’s argument that the prosecution should not be allowed because the CPS had already considered the matter and decided to bring charges only for “failing to keep a proper lookout”.

A private prosecution is commenced by requesting a summons from the magistrates’ court. A summons will only be issued if the magistrates are satisfied that (1) the allegation is of an offence known to the law, (2) the essential ingredients of the offence appear to be present, (3) the offence alleged is not brought too late, (4) the court has jurisdiction, and (5) the informant has the necessary authority. Further, some types of proceedings require the consent of a judge or the attorney general, including prosecutions for criminal libel against anyone responsible for the publication of a newspaper, prosecutions for incitement to racial hatred and prosecutions for assisting suicide.

The tests a Crown prosecutor must apply in deciding whether to pursue a prosecution (ie whether there is a realistic prospect of conviction and whether prosecution is in the public interest) do not apply to a private prosecutor. In practice, however, if the tests are not met the case is unlikely to get very far. This is because of the power given to the CPS to take over a case in order to put a stop to it. The CPS guidance says that a private prosecution “should be taken over and stopped if, upon review of the case papers, either the evidential sufficiency stage or the public interest stage of the full code test is not met”. The courts have pointed out that if the CPS apply precisely the same test when deciding whether to discontinue a case as they do when deciding whether to start proceedings in the first place then the right of private prosecution would be undermined. The fact that the CPS would not have brought the proceedings itself should not preclude a private prosecution going ahead.

The CPS guidance also states that it may be necessary to stop a private prosecution even where the evidential and public interest tests are met, if there is “a particular need to do so, such as where the prosecution is likely to damage the interests of justice”. One of the examples given is “cases where it can be said that the prosecution is vexatious… or malicious”. A private prosecution which is politically motivated, for example, may well be cut off for this reason.

So, in principle, it is possible for a member of the public to prosecute a public figure for an offence under SOCPA or indeed for fraud. However, even assuming that the difficulties outlined above can be overcome there are two further practical problems. First, a private prosecutor does not have any of the powers of the police to seize evidence or question suspects, and he or she has no right of access to statements, evidence, or other documents held by the CPS. Putting together sufficient evidence to amount to a “case to answer” on the basis of publicly available material will often be tricky. Second, the court may make an order that a party pay costs that have been incurred as a result of an unnecessary or improper act or omission. If it considers that the prosecution was completely misconceived and the defendant incurred costs as a result then there may be a substantial bill to pay.

Finally, all you Guardian-reading monarchists will be pleased to be reminded that the monarch is immune from being sued or prosecuted in the courts. So the Queen can demonstrate in Parliament Square without prior authorisation to her heart’s content.

Do you have a civil liberties or human rights question for the Liberty lawyers? Post it in our Liberty Clinic open thread.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


China and Taiwan presidents swap telegrams

Hu Jintao and Ma Ying-jeou talk of peace in a sign of improved relations that could lead to historic summit

First came direct flights, then freight links, and now a single telegram. The presidents of Taiwan and China exchanged direct messages today for the first time in 60 years, in the latest sign of their thawing relations.

Hu Jintao wrote to Taiwan’s Ma Ying-jeou to mark the latter’s election as chairman of the Nationalist party.

Bacuse of the enduring mutual sensitivities, the message was sent simply to Mr Ma, while Ma’s reply was addressed to Hu as general secretary of the Communist party.

Beijing still claims sovereignty over Taiwan, which has been self-ruled since Chiang Kai-shek fled there following his defeat in the civil war in 1949. China has warned it could use force if Taipei pursued formal independence.

“I hope our two parties can continue to promote peaceful cross-strait development, deepen mutual trust, bring good news to compatriots on both sides and create a revival of the great Chinese race,” said Hu in his telegram.

“We should continue efforts to consolidate peace in the Taiwan Strait and rebuild regional stability,” Ma replied, adding that they should “put aside disputes”.

Ma was elected president in spring last year on a platform of improving relations with China and because of widespread dissatisfaction with the ruling Democratic People’s party.

But while he has signed landmark trade deals, he has avoided political issues, due in large part to powerful anti-Beijing sentiment on the island.

Lin Chong-pin, a strategic studies professor at Tamkang University in Taipei, told Reuters that the telegram suggested the Chinese leader wants to meet Ma eventually. “It’s sort of expected … It is in Hu Jintao’s benefit or advantage to meet,” Lin said. “It would be a personal feat.”

But analysts believe both sides may take years to weigh up the risks before proceeding.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


Is Spotify iPhone app too like iTunes?

Streaming music service Spotify submits iPhone app to Apple, but analysts say it might be too close to iTunes to be approved

European streaming music service Spotify has developed an application to use their service on the popular iPhone, but it must first submit it for approval to iPhone maker Apple, which could reject it on grounds that Spotify competes with its own iTunes music store.

Apple has approved applications from streaming music providers Pandora and Last.fm and satellite broadcaster Sirius XM, but those services are more like streaming radio, with Pandora and Last.fm allowing people to listen to a specific genre of music or music similar to listeners favourite artist. Spotify allows people to choose specific songs to listen to and create playlists of those songs.

Speaking to paidContent, Spotify CEO Daniel Ek said he expects Apple to approve the application in the next few weeks, and he added, “Apple has already approved several other music services such as Last.fm, Deezer and Pandora. We very much look forward to people being able to access their Spotify library wherever they might be and we’ve spent significant time and resources to ensure we’ve stuck to Apple’s developer guidelines point by point.”

Apple might be more open to approving Spotify’s application because it is in talks with music companies and could be bringing out its own streaming music service, although such a service has been rumoured for years. Apple and the music industry might be trying to increase revenues from digital music by offering value-added bundles of content including video, interviews and streamed music.
 
Spotify has two services: a free service supported by advertising; and a premium service that allows users to listen to ad-free streams for £9.99 a month.

The iPhone application will be restricted to Spotify’s premium users. Some iPhone applications such as voice over internet service Skype are restricted to only working on Wi-Fi, but the Spotify application will work over Wi-Fi and also 3G mobile phone data networks.

One of the biggest draws for Spotify’s application will be the ability to listen to one’s favourite music even when no internet connection is available.

With advertising supported businesses coming under pressure during the recession, Spotify must convert more users from the free model to its premium model to succeed where others have failed, says Mark Mulligan, vice president and research director of consumer product strategy at Forrester Research.

The problem is that the premium streaming music businesses have a dismal record of failure in the UK, he said. Virgin and HMV shuttered their premium music streaming businesses, with HMV relaunching a new offering. Napster has between 50,000 and 60,000 UK subscribers, numbers so modest that it shifted its European headquarters to Germany.

Although Spotify has not discussed publicly how many premium subscribers it has, Mulligan estimates that the figure is in line with the industry standard 1% of its user base. “You have to really detest ads to pay £9.99 a month not to get them,” he said.

To survive and add more paying customers, companies like Spotify must launch value added-services like this mobile application.

Spotify is currently not available in the US, and the application will likewise only be available in the west European and Scandinavian markets where Spotify operates. However, this could be an important step towards a US launch.

Pandora and Sirius XM saw great success with their iPhone apps. Pandora executive Tom Conrad said they were adding a new listener every 2 seconds in the weeks after their iPhone application launched. Having the application ready for the US launch could be key to Spotify’s expansion plans.

On Spotify’s blog post announcing the availability of the application, many users are asking when it will be available for other major mobile phone platforms including Nokia handsets running its S60 smart phone operating system and handsets running Google’s Android OS. The company has already showed off a demo of the application running on Android earlier this summer.

The question remains whether Apple approve Spotify’s application. Adding the caveat that one should never try to second guess Apple, Mulligan said he would not be surprised if the application was rejected.

Apple already rejected the Podcaster app because it duplicated functionality of iTunes. While Spotify have been quite clever in releasing a video demonstration of the app to whet customers’ appetite, Mulligan said it might be too good, too similar to Apple’s own iTunes store experience to win approval. 

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


Kayaker makes record 55m waterfall drop

Watch Tyler Bradt execute a world-record drop over the Palouse falls in Washington state

This has to be seen to be believed.

When Tyler Bradt shot down Palouse falls, he broke a world record and his paddle, but he survived virtually unscathed.

Bradt achieved the feat in April, but the video has only just emerged.

After plunging 55 metres (180ft) he surfaced after seven seconds only slightly out of breath and with a sprained wrist.

“I actually expected more of an impact,” he told the Seattle Times. “… considering the waterfall, the injuries were pretty minor.”

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


Should I ditch my secret millionaire?

A reader wonders whether finding out about her new boyfriend’s hidden wealth will jeopardise their relationship

Every week a Guardian Money reader submits a question, and it’s up to you to help him or her out – a selection of the best answers will appear in Saturday’s paper.

This week’s question

I have been seeing a lovely guy I met on a dating website. We get on ridiculously well but, unknown to him, I’ve found out he’s a millionaire. I’m uncomfortable that our lives are so very different, and worry he might see me as a “gold digger”. My friends say I’m in a flap about nothing and it’s a no-brainer! How do I resolve this? Do I finish it? Or am I being prejudiced against the rich?

What are your thoughts?

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


Shaun Tan’s unexpected details

The author of some of the most startling graphic stories of recent years is not what you’d expect of an artist, but then his are not your typical picture books

“Drawing a good picture is like telling a really good lie – the key is in the incidental detail,” says Shaun Tan. Fortunately, the Australian artist’s award-winning picture books are anything but short on detail. Each spread drops the reader into a surreal world of bizarre animals, skew-whiff buildings, dreamlike landscapes and invented languages, the magical realism and conceptual playfulness of Tan’s paintings underscoring the simple language of the tales – “illustrated modern fables” as he calls them.

In the stunning, wordless graphic novel The Arrival, sober-looking characters dressed in 1930s-style suits and bowler hats are accompanied on their journeys through a mysterious city by strange creatures reminiscent of Philip Pullman’s daemons (only much, much weirder). The Lost Thing is a huge metal contraption from some other world, “hidden” by the boy who finds it in his parents’ otherwise relatively conventional house; next to the words “nobody understands”, the central character in The Red Tree is seen wearing a weighty diving mask, huddled in a glass bottle on a stormy shoreline, in one of the most unnerving insights into depression ever drawn.

“The detail adds an element of unexpected something,” Tan explains. “All fiction is false; what makes it convincing is that it runs alongside the truth. The real world has lots of incidental details, so a painting also has to have that element of imperfection and irregularity, those incidental details. I’m constantly testing with the details. I go on a hunch and try it out. I might have a character and have a feeling that he needs to have a hat and so I put it in and it feels right and then I realise that he needs to have a hat because he’s trying to hide something.”

The result of this careful attention to detail is that Tan’s worlds, however fantastical they may appear on first glance, have their own internal logic. It is what he describes as “groundedness”, and he regards it as crucial to the success of the stories.

“By itself, just to draw crazy creatures has limited appeal – if I had to give up one thing it would be the wild imagination. When the work becomes too detached from ordinary life it starts to fall apart. Fantasy needs to have some connection with reality or it becomes of its own interest only, insular. In The Lost Thing, to have creatures flying around is unsatisfactory without the context. It works because it exists in opposition to the world in the rest of the story.”

To meet the man behind the wildly surreal pictures brings home that sense of opposites. Compact, neatly dressed and precise in speech, the initial impression is less the artist bubbling over with crazy creativity, than an accountant, albeit a very bright and charming one. Tan speaks thoughtfully, carefully about his work and there’s a clue to the origins of this precision when he talks about his upbringing in Perth, western Australia. His father was an architect and Tan recalls spending hours as a child drawing pictures on the back of discarded architectural sketches.

“I learnt some of my style from him,” says Tan, “including the extreme attention to detail. There’s that sense that if you do something it has to be well-crafted and it’s more fun that way and you get a better thing at the end.”

Yet despite parents with an interest in art and a childhood spent carefully observing and documenting in pictures the world around him – “I was always head down, looking at objects on the beach, almost fixated on collecting seashells and bumping into something that’s unexpected” – it was not a given that Tan would pursue illustration as a career. He flirted with the idea of becoming a scientist – a fascination carried over into The Lost Thing, where the images are framed with collages from physics and maths textbooks.

But, at 16, he had his first illustration published in an SF magazine and discovered the thrill of seeing his work in print. “One of the attractions of working on the books is the idea of people you don’t know seeing your work and forming an opinion about it. Seeing your work in print is exciting, especially when you’re young. It’s that feeling that you have some effect on the world outside of your immediate neighbourhood,” says Tan.

A joint degree in English and fine art followed, while he continued to sell illustrations to magazines. But even then he wasn’t convinced that he could make a living as an artist. “I didn’t want to starve in a garret. For me, the main thing was to secure a livelihood and then explore artistic interests. I was fairly conservative like that,” says Tan, laughing now at the memory.

He decided to give art a year after finishing university and see how it went. He soon found that, by saying yes to everything that he was offered, from commercial illustration and fantasy novel book covers to occasional cartoons, and drawings of microscopes, he could make his way and then start creating his own books.

Given his secure, happy childhood and what seems to have been a relatively straightforward path into a successful career, it is perhaps surprising that Tan’s work is quite as dark as it is. Although often categorised as a creator of children’s “picture books”, the deeper, bleaker issues he tackles belies any such pigeonholing. The Red Tree is a blistering portrait of depression, while The Arrival is a masterful examination of the immigrant experience, and The Rabbits (illustrated by Tan but written by John Marsden) is a powerful allegory of environmental destruction. While The Arrival, thanks to its sheer length and sepia tones if nothing else, falls most easily into “graphic novel” territory, Tan’s other books occupy a kind of hinterland which can make them difficult to market.

“None of my books are for anybody – I don’t have any image of a child reading my book when I produce them,” says Tan. “It’s unfortunate sometimes that they are marketed to children. It’s good that kids get them, but that can exclude adults.

“One bookseller in Australia took the children’s book award sticker off The Red Tree as he felt he could sell more that way, and sold an extra 30-40 copies a month. It’s about simple things like font size – people think they can judge the age a book is for by the font size and assume that it’s for little kids if it has a big font, but that’s silly. I don’t worry too much about those things as the creator because I figure that the books will find their own audience and sometimes I like the idea that they can give adults a surprise pleasure.”

There is indeed always a “surprise pleasure” despite the seriousness of the topics Tan takes on. The books are leavened not only in the flashes of humour in Tan’s richly imaginative drawings, which he describes as “conscious dreaming”, but the thread of hope and compassion woven through every tale, however initially bleak.

“I think stories that represent the world as hopeless or dark are valid and some of them I really enjoy but the truth is that there is hopefulness in every situation,” says Tan. Of The Red Tree, he says that “the expression of depression is somehow refreshing. You can deal with things if you acknowledge them – it makes you feel good to acknowledge stuff.” Even in The Rabbits, although the “text is grim”, the images are redemptive, especially as it ends with “two misunderstood beings trying to communicate with each other across pool of stars, to overcome their cultural blindness and ask questions about what they are doing.”

These kinds of attempts to communicate across divides are a key theme in Tan’s books. His characters are often outsiders who have trouble articulating their feelings, something Tan says he recognises from when he was growing up and used drawing to help to express himself. The characters find themselves in strange situations but, ultimately, cope by “using empathy to get through, overcoming apathy.”

Tan is reluctant to delve too deeply into the “meanings” of his fables. Towards the end of The Lost Thing he writes, “Well, that’s it. That’s the story. Not especially profound, I know, but I never said it was. And don’t ask me what the moral is.” When pressed on the The Red Tree and the sudden chink of light at the end of the story with the appearance of a magical tree, he suggests that
“The Red Tree is there because this girl has somehow persisted and if there is any moral to the story – if you had to force a moral at it would be something to do with persistence.”

Morals or not, what shines through Tan’s work is an essential humanity, whether it is arrivals in a new city silently describing their journeys from war zones to a fragile new life, a metal mammoth happy to be found a place where he doesn’t quite fit, or a girl who finds a speck of hope, “bright and vivid, quietly waiting”, where previously there was only darkness.

• Shaun Tan’s latest work, Tales from Outer Suburbia (Templar) is an anthology of 15 very short illustrated stories. Each one is about a strange situation or event that occurs in an otherwise familiar suburban world.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds


Irrigation is key to food security

Irrigation seems to have been left off the agenda when it comes to discussing food security in Uganda. It needs to be added now, argues Richard M Kavuma

As we now know, the people of Katine, the wider Teso region and other parts of Uganda are bracing themselves for famine following back-to-back drought. This is, of course, bad news, which makes the recent G8 pledge to support Africa to feed itself all the more timely. But what bothers me is the failure of the Ugandan government and indeed its donors – including the UK – to realise that simplistic solutions will only be stop-gap measures. Yes, there is talk about fertilizers and drought-resistant crop varieties, but governments have pretty much maintained a business-as-usual approach to agriculture. The United Nations Conference on Trade and Development’s 2009 Least Developed Countries report says as much.

People in Katine realise that the weather is changing and many ask what is happening to “their” world. A year ago, one village leader’s message to the G8 heads of state was that they should help Katine plant trees to help stabilise the unpredictable weather. Of course, planting a tree in Katine is no panacea for all the crimes committed against the planet, especially by wealthier countries, but the 55-year-old village chairman was thinking along the right lines. But what does his president, Yoweri Museveni, in Kampala think? That it is all right for natural forests like Mabira to be replaced with sugar cane farms because sugar cane companies will pay billions of Ugandan shillings in taxes.

One painful thing about this drought/famine scenario was echoed by Stephen Ochola, Soroti district chairman, the other day: How can Egypt and Israel, which are largely deserts, grow fruits and export juice, while Uganda, blessed with rich soils, rainfall and lakes and rivers, starves? Why, Ochola wondered, can’t Uganda start seriously promoting irrigation to supplement the rains when necessary?

Out of Uganda’s estimated 400,000 hectares of irrigable land, barely 5% is under irrigation – and these are large-scale farms. The government has for years talked about harnessing water for production, but there is too little being done.

People must find creative ways to harness water resources to make irrigation by smallholder farmers possible. But they need creative, committed leadership. It is expensive, of course, but who said saving lives was going to be cheap? For without a change in approach this is what it will come down to – saving people from starving to death.

Another issue that does not feature in the G8 text was brought up by farmer Julius Eilu, who is already having trouble feeding his family of nine children. Asked what he would do to cope, Eilu said: “Perhaps I should stop fathering children.” This is a telling statement by a father in an area where children come with some pride.

Eilu’s president in Kampala sees no problem with Uganda’s population growth rate of 3.2% per year. In fact he thinks Uganda’s population of 30 million is too small. Yet as families have more children that they can hardly afford, farmland gets fragmented into small plots for the many siblings, productivity reduces and the dependence ratio grows. Couple that with unpredictable weather and the business-as-usual approach of the state and you have the recipe for a perpetually food-insecure, poor country.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009 | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds