Note: In our constant efforts to bring you the most compelling Phish coverage anywhere, we offer two points of view on Phish’s first California show in over six years. First we have general reflections from our Editor-in-Chief Kayceman, followed by a fresh perspective from our Associate Editor Dennis Cook. Enjoy.
Words by: Kayceman | Images by: Susan J. Weiand
Phish :: 08.05.09 :: Shoreline Amphitheatre :: View Mountain View, CA
Kayceman shares a few thoughts on Phish at Shoreline:
MIKE’S BAND
![]()
src="http://images.jambase.com/bands/phish/090805_weiand/12_1.jpg">Mike Gordon :: 08.05 :: Shoreline Amphitheatre |
Since when is this Gordo‘s band? Don’t get me wrong, dude’s been dropping bombs forever, but I’ve heard lots of chatter about individual band members, how great Trey is playing now that he’s sober and focused (true), how strong Page sounds (no doubt), but after watching Mike control the entire show last evening I am compelled to champion his cause. Whether he was challenging Trey on “Chalk Dust,” crushing the funk on “Cities,” or pushing his fat bass notes into truly dark territory on “Down With Disease” and the hard-earned “Mike’s Song,” Gordo was the dominator at Shoreline.
NEW SONGS
Alright, no sugar here, let’s tell it like it is. We got a lot of new songs at Shoreline and we didn’t get the good ones. And I get it. A band always wants to play what’s new, and any healthy band has to be engaged in fresh material, but overall the selections from last night didn’t do it for me. Here are the new ones from Shoreline:
“Time Turns Elastic” – Time turns boring. Like many of their new ones, there’s a really strong jam at the end, but the set-up is too formulaic, almost like they are covering themselves in a way. Put it back in the oven, I bet it bakes into something nice, but it’s not ready yet.
“Stealing Time From The Faulty Plan” – I dig it, and definitely the best new one from Shoreline. A little like “Character O,” but I also like that track so we’re doing okay. The “got a blank space where my mind should be” chorus really works and Trey’s guitar is mean. More like this, please.
“Backwards Down The Number Line” – Not bad. I hated the placement as set two opener, but it’s a nice song that like “Time Turns Elastic” built up steam as it went. At the end of the day, I’m just not into the introspective songwriter thing with Phish; it’s not why we go to Phish.
“Let Me Lie” – No. No. Seriously, no! I don’t want to think of Trey riding his bike or taking off his shirt to feel it burn or using the brakes when he goes down hill. The metaphors are all wrong. At a rock & roll show we don’t use brakes, we want to fly off the rails because we’re going so fast.
KEEPING IT AFLOAT
![]()
src="http://images.jambase.com/bands/phish/090805_weiand/29_1.jpg">Phish :: 08.05 :: Shoreline Amphitheatre |
For all my shit talking I actually really liked the show and think the band sounds really good right now. Song selection wasn’t my favorite but a few incredibly well played numbers kept the night afloat. The set one combos of “Chalk Dust”/”Divided Sky” (where Trey nailed the shit out of it) and “Suzy”/”David Bowie” were more than enough to satiate the packed house. Set two was carried by a spacey “Down With Disease” and then the “Maze,” “Mike’s” (a lil slow out of the gate but definitely worth the wait) > “Simple,” “Weekapaug.” The “Maze” was completely demented and likely the song of the night. If “Maze” wasn’t the highpoint, then “Mike’s” was, as shit got primordial in the back section. And just hearing “Bowie” and “Maze” on the same night is enough. Never in all my years have I seen both in the same show. Well played, lads.
SOLID B
For their efforts at Shoreline, I give Phish a solid B. And coming off Red Rocks and going into The Gorge, two mammoth sets of shows, a solid B on a Wednesday night with flashes of brilliance ain’t too bad.
Continue reading for Dennis Cook’s review of Shoreline…
Words by: Dennis Cook | Images by: Susan J. Weiand
Phish :: 08.05.09 :: Shoreline Amphitheatre :: Mountain View, CA
![]()
src="http://images.jambase.com/bands/phish/090805_weiand/16_1.jpg">Phish :: 08.05 :: Shoreline Amphitheatre |
Enthusiasm is much harder to offer than respect. While passingly familiar with the broad strokes of Phish‘s 26-year career, this show was only my third time seeing them in the flesh. Always feeling an outsider to their very codified clubhouse, I just let them be, marveled at what they’d achieved against any “normal” industry standards and patted my many Phish lovin’ friends on the back as they celebrated this band. However, I walked into Shoreline with a real zeal to unlock their zeitgeist, preconceptions left in a jar at home, and discovered a world class quartet with a vibrant, peculiar, fiercely engaging identity. And they were a shitload of fun, too.
Immediately I was struck by how twisty they are, but in such a friendly way. It would be so easy for this music to veer into artiness and highbrow distance but it really never did. Yes, there were a few meandering stretches but Phish 3.0 seems like a band with a mission, and at least from my newbie’s POV, that mission appears to be to shore up every good thing that’s distinct about them. The wandering is to be expected when juggling such primal ooze but they never really dropped the ball and their idiosyncratic internal logic swept one up in a journey, where time was both elastic and stolen, that will take awhile for my brain to untangle. I’m not sure they were trying to craft a cohesive narrative a la Phil & Friends but there was a scale of storytelling and brave, balls out execution that felt, well, epic (and apologies for falling back on that hoary jam-scene cliche but it fits).
![]()
src="http://images.jambase.com/bands/phish/090805_weiand/22_1.jpg">Trey Anastasio :: 08.05 :: Shoreline Amphitheatre |
By the time they hit the rawk-tastic “Chalk Dust Torture” in set one I was pretty sold by the curious mixture of elements they stir – Frampton-like classic rock moves mingling with African high life, brainy electric jazz, calypso, barbershop harmonizing, dub accents, bar band moxie and way more. It’s so freakin’ illogical that it transcends any simple descriptor, a language separate from rock’s Rosetta Stone that others can play at but only these four dudes can actually converse smoothly in, a lovely chatter that emerges when they drink up the moment and move off the guide rails. To wit, the jam in “Chalk Dust,” which wobbled on the song’s axis, bellowing sea bottom bass and jittery sprinter’s heart drums being clawed at by hungry guitar that teetered between madness and Joe Pass finesse, wound into a flurry of keys unleashed by Page that actually quickened my pulse. There’s SO much going on in their music that it’s a smorgasbord to choose from, each person free to sample bites or just take in the general yumminess.
And there’s the no small matter of the abundant love their incredibly dedicated throng project towards the stage. Looking around during this show all I saw were people lit up from within by what Phish was creating on stage, and it’s not hard to surrender to that affectionate, alive riptide and join them in celebrating life and wholly engaged music making. Regardless of my ignorance, I love hearing the oddball titles of their tunes murmured adoringly on folk’s lips – “Golgi,” “Weekapaug,” “Ya Mar.” It’s a foreign tongue to be sure, and while FAR from fluent I left this gig determined to do a lil’ Berlitz blitz to bring myself up to speed, a surprising commitment given the shortness of time and abundance of music already on my plate. My anxiousness to educate myself speaks volumes about the intensity of what they laid down.
![]()
src="http://images.jambase.com/bands/phish/090805_weiand/32_1.jpg">Phish :: 08.05 :: Shoreline Amphitheatre |
I can’t rightly say if this was a “great show” or merely a very good one. I simply don’t have the frame of reference to speak with any authority. What I can say is that despite their massive individual talents it was the group dynamic, their collective noise, especially in the second set that floored me. It’s a sound that runs down jubilation and finds the sweet spot between simplistic fare (there’s a goodly amount of pure cock rock to Phish but also a fair bit of nursery rhyme thinking) and stratospheric, highly theoretical muso smarty pants-ed-ness. More simply, Phish is a fucking platypus, fuzzy but laying hard-shelled eggs, a thumb in the eye to those who stuff things into neat genres. And they did all this with such exposed emotion, raggedly baroque eloquence and gee-whiz bravado that my wig was rightfully flipped.
A few other scattershot highlights: The swerving blur of “David Bowie” that closed set one; Page’s Chucho Valdes-esque piano throughout the night and his strong Traffic-era Winwood lead vocal on their tremendous cover of The Velvet Underground’s “Oh Sweet Nothin’;” Trey‘s heartfelt reading of Los Lobos’ “When The Circus Comes,” even if it put the brakes on the momentum they were building at that point; the wacky juxtapositions of mood and tempo; the way Trey occasionally brought to bear a very Derek and the Dominoes blues guitar growl and vocal yearning; the disco-y take on the Talking Heads’ “Cities;” the wicked turns of “Maze;” their unbridled love for people with “a ticket stub in their hand;” Chris Kuroda‘s Dumbledore-ian lighting wizardry; and the vast distances they traveled, often within a single piece, which ranged from the consciously gigantic and involved down to music box delicacy.
Instead of feeling overwhelmed (which their music can EASILY make one feel) I experienced a tiny taste of what’s kept millions on the ride for decades, understanding that while they’re the focal point, the enzyme, Phish is a collaborative effort produced by a combination of these extraordinarily gifted players, a mind-boggling catalog AND the writhing, hands in the air masses that gather around them. The morning after I can honestly say I finally dig Phish. Go figure…
Phish :: 08.05.09 :: Shoreline Amphitheatre :: View Mountain View, CA
Set I: Golgi Apparatus, Halley’s Comet, Chalk Dust Torture, The Divided Sky, When the Circus Comes, Time Turns Elastic, Ya Mar, Stealing Time From The Faulty Plan, Suzy Greenberg, David Bowie
Set II: Backwards Down the Number Line, Down With Disease > Limb By Limb, Oh Sweet Nothin’, Cities > Maze, Mike’s Song > Simple, Weekapaug Groove
E: Let Me Lie, Bold As Love
For more pics of this show go here.
Phish perform again Friday and Saturday night at The Gorge in George, WA. Check back for live Tweets, setlists, pics and full reviews. Complete Phish tour dates available
href="http://www.jambase.com/Artists/2698/Phish/Shows">here.
Just like Leg I of Phish’s Summer Tour, JamBase will be at every stop with more coverage than you’ll find anywhere! Keep up to speed with all things Phish at jambase.com/phish.
JamBase | Awash
Go See Live Music!
